Secret Santa & White Elephant Candy

Looking for candy for a white elephant swap or a funny candy gift for Secret Santa? You have a budget, a deadline and zero ideas, and we can help. This collection is packed with gag-gift candy that gets a laugh, a gasp or a "wait, what is that?" the second the wrapping paper comes off, and most picks cost less than $30.

Think a unicorn that dispenses candy from exactly where you think, a tiny sour candy toilet with plunger lollipops, a gummy worm that weighs over 2 pounds and a jelly bean game where every bean is a gamble. Everything here is $30 or less, which fits most Secret Santa and white elephant price caps.

Pair two picks to clear $30 and US shipping is free (it's $5.95 under $30). One heads-up: the Lil Nitro Very Hot Gummy Bear is not for anyone under 14, per the maker.

Shipping & returns

Free US shipping
On every order of $30 or more. Mix and match any candy to get there.
Under $30
Flat $5.95 US shipping.
Canada
We ship to the US and Canada only. Canadian orders pay the carrier rate (USPS or DHL Express) shown at checkout.
No returns on food
Because candy is food, we can't accept returns, opened or unopened.
Damaged, melted, wrong or missing?
Contact us within 48 hours of delivery with your order number and photos, and we'll refund or reship the affected items.
Cancellations & refunds
You can cancel an order until it ships. Approved refunds go back to your original payment method within 10 business days.

Read the full refund policy

Candy shopping FAQ

Everything you need to know before you check out.

How do I get free shipping?

Spend $30 or more on any mix of candy and US shipping is free. US orders under $30 ship for a flat $5.95.

Do you ship outside the US?

Only to Canada. Canadian orders pay the carrier rate (USPS or DHL Express) shown at checkout, and any import duties or taxes are the recipient's responsibility. We don't currently ship to other countries.

Are products sold individually?

Yes. Each listing shows its own price, and you can add as many of any item as you like.

Where can I find ingredients and allergen information?

Ingredients and allergens vary by brand and are printed on each package. Contact us if you need details before ordering.

What is your return policy?

Because candy is food, we can't accept returns, opened or unopened. If anything arrives damaged, melted, wrong or missing, contact us within 48 hours of delivery with your order number and photos, and we'll refund or reship the affected items. You can cancel an order until it ships. Approved refunds go to your original payment method within 10 business days. Full refund policy.